In 2018, the UK witnessed the catastrophic collapse of Carillion, one of the country’s largest construction firms, which left behind unfinished projects, thousands of job losses, and over £7 billion in liabilities. Carillion’s downfall wasn’t caused by a sudden market crash or unforeseen global crisis. It was a textbook example of failed corporate governance. A lack of accountability, poor oversight from the board, and short-sighted financial management led the company to overstate its profits and take on unsustainable contracts. As a result, suppliers and workers were left unpaid, and the government was forced to step in and manage abandoned public contracts.

Corporate governance, as aligned with the UK Corporate Governance Code, refers to the system by which companies are directed and controlled, ensuring accountability, fairness, and transparency in a company’s relationship with its stakeholders. It encompasses the roles and responsibilities of the board, management, shareholders, and other stakeholders in overseeing the company’s strategic direction, managing risks, ensuring ethical conduct, and promoting long-term success.

Carillion’s devastating collapse served as a reminder of the critical importance of sound corporate governance. When corporate governance fails, the impact ripples far beyond the boardroom, affecting employees, suppliers, investors, and even the wider economy. For governance professionals, Carillion’s demise is a stark lesson in what happens when oversight, transparency, and accountability fall by the wayside.

Why Corporate Governance is Crucial

Corporate governance is not just a box-ticking exercise for compliance purposes; it is the backbone of a company’s long-term success. Here are five reasons why strong governance is essential, supported by real-world examples:

1) Promotes Transparency and Trust

Strong corporate governance fosters transparency, which is essential in building trust with investors, customers, and stakeholders. Take the example of Tesco in 2014, which overstated its profits by £250 million. The scandal led to significant losses in shareholder value and damaged the company’s reputation. By ensuring transparent financial reporting and regular audits, boards can avoid misleading stakeholders and damaging the company’s credibility.

2) Prevents Fraud and Mismanagement

Effective governance ensures that no single individual or group can control the company without proper checks and balances. Enron, the US energy giant, manipulated its financial reports for years, hiding billions in debt, which eventually led to its bankruptcy in 2001. Enron’s collapse resulted in devastating financial losses and a loss of trust in corporate America. Strong governance systems, such as independent audits and clear separation of duties, can help prevent such disastrous outcomes.

3) Ensures Long-Term Sustainability

Good corporate governance encourages boards to focus on long-term success rather than short-term gains. An example is Unilever, whose CEO Paul Polman shifted the company’s focus toward sustainability, ensuring long-term growth. By prioritising ethical practices and sustainability, Unilever has maintained steady growth and earned the trust of consumers. Boards must develop strategies that consider the long-term impact on stakeholders, not just short-term profits.

4) Protects Shareholders’ Interests

Governance exists to protect the interests of shareholders, ensuring that the company is run efficiently and ethically. BP’s Deepwater Horizon oil spill in 2010 was, in part, the result of cost-cutting measures and poor safety protocols. The disaster not only led to financial losses and environmental damage but also wiped billions off BP’s market value. Boards that prioritise safety and ethical practices, even at the cost of short-term profits, ultimately protect shareholder value.

5) Facilitates Efficient Decision-Making

Good governance structures enable swift and efficient decision-making. In times of crisis, this can be the difference between a company’s survival and failure. Consider how Marks & Spencer (M&S) has adapted in the face of modern retail challenges. With clear governance protocols and a board that is agile, M&S has been able to make critical decisions quickly, allowing the company to pivot and remain competitive in a challenging retail environment.

How Boards Can Implement Strong Corporate Governance

1. Independence of the Board: A key factor in good governance is having an independent board that can provide unbiased oversight. Non-executive directors should challenge the CEO and senior management, ensuring that decisions are in the company’s best interests. Independence prevents conflicts of interest and ensures that management decisions are scrutinised thoroughly.

2. Regular Audits and Financial Transparency: Boards should ensure that the company undergoes regular audits, both internal and external, to identify any risks or mismanagement early. Transparent financial reporting should be a priority, with clear communication to shareholders and stakeholders.

3. Risk Management Systems: Every board should have robust risk management processes in place to identify, assess, and mitigate potential risks. From market fluctuations to cybersecurity threats, boards need to be proactive in addressing vulnerabilities before they escalate into major issues.

4. Diversity and Inclusion: Diversity on boards leads to better decision-making. A mix of perspectives, experiences, and backgrounds contributes to more innovative solutions and reduces the likelihood of groupthink. Companies like Lloyds Banking Group have made strides in ensuring gender diversity, improving their governance and decision-making processes.

5. Sustainability and Ethics: Companies must embed sustainability and ethical practices into their governance structures. This is not only about environmental sustainability but also about how the company treats its employees, customers, and the communities in which it operates. Ethical governance ensures that companies maintain a good reputation and build trust with stakeholders.

Strengthen Your Corporate Governance Today

Corporate governance isn’t an option; it’s a necessity. The Carillion collapse shows what can happen when governance is neglected. It’s time for boards to take responsibility and strengthen their oversight, transparency, and long-term strategies. Whether you’re a director or a governance professional, you have the power to ensure your company’s success and sustainability.

For an independent board performance review from industry experts please get in touch.

To receive more insights and tips on improving corporate governance, subscribe to our email list today. Stay informed about the latest trends, case studies, and best practices that will help you lead your organisation to success while safeguarding its future. Don’t let your company become the next cautionary tale—start building a culture of strong corporate governance now.